Best Reviews

Varathane Vs Minwax

The re-stain and wipe of a 4′ square took about 30 minutes. The Clorox wipes only took so much effort and a 20′ square took 2-1/2 hours. The Murphy’s Oil Soap, then Clorox wipes, then paper toweling of a 40′ square took less than an hour and the results were perfect. They floors were dry in minutes and tomorrow I will polish them with a water-based polish. I’ve been working on a matching backdrop/floor combo for my studio. I ordered in long planks of cedar and cut them to size.

In this case, go over the dry stain with a coat of Top Coat, let dry and re-stain. This will even out your surface for application. Even though the Gel Stain has some urethane in it, I recommend 2-3 coats of Top Coat for protection.

Gel Stains

A second coat seemed to make the stain slightly darker and more uniform, but it wasn’t a dramatic difference. The top coat deepened the black color without obscuring the wood grain. These products dry a bit rough and need sanding between coats, which makes it harder to get a rich color with a smooth surface. If I need to sand and baby it, then I might as well just stain then finish the wood in two steps. So, what would be the best way for me to approach this?

The most common clear finish is polyurethane, a tough polymer coating that’s durable, long-lasting, and easy to apply. Second, I recently had my front doors restained. I also hada wood mantle, also stained, installed on my back porch fireplace . Both said that I should apply varnish every couple years for general protection and to avoid fading. I would ask minwax if applying outdoor varnish would prevent any of the problems they think you will have. Probably not, but it could be a simple solution.

Best Deck Paint For Your Money

The graining is much more delicate than pine, and it tends to have green undertones. I love the beachy look that sun bleached gives wood. It’s not as grey as driftwood, but it still feels light bright and coastal. Weathered Wood Accelerator is a stain by Varathane. It is gray in color and has a lot of blue or purple undertones. I really, really love the look of Weathered Oak.

Lacquer vs. polyurethane: Paint pros & cons to make informed decisions – SILive.com

Lacquer vs. polyurethane: Paint pros & cons to make informed decisions.

Posted: Thu, 03 Sep 2015 07:00:00 GMT [source]

This should be ok if you gave the stain 3-4 days to properly dry out. You’ll want the oil-based drying agent to completely vaporize from the stain before applying the water-based finish. Recently I doubled the machines within my business in order to expand the crew.

Which Stain Is Better For Hardwood Floors

Tung oil is more water resistant than linseed or other oils, therefore it would be a better oil for exterior use, but much more expensive. Yes, definitely love the internet and all the confusion and misunderstandings that the written word can cause. I think that wars have been fought over less?!? Like you mentioned, their old methods of prepping the floor and applying the poly were no longer feasible with the new finishes.

Be careful with any water-based product on wood. Unless you really know what you’re doing, you can warp it and/or raise the grain on it. The more humid it is, the longer time it will take for the odor to go away.

Sanding sealers have zinc stearates , sometimes labeled mineral soaps, in them which makes it easier to sand but also makes the seal coat softer than the top coat. This can lead to white scratches under the top coat when bumped or hit. Pre stain conditioners are used for woods like cherry, and maple, which can have severe variations in color due to the way they grow. pine, and birch are the most common that I know about.

It can be applied overanywood but is especially necessary when working with soft or porous woods like pine, alder, birch, and maple. It’s a good thing you mentioned what door you’re going to finish. Bathroom doors have to deal with constant moisture and warm air which cause wood corruption.

Topcoating The Gel Stain

No, there is no real difference in VOC levels , per the technical department at Minwax . They are both compliant with state and federal laws, too. But, because DuraSeal dries faster, it doesn’t smell quite as long.

  • Stocked alongside its classic counterparts at almost any hardware store, gel stain is rather similar in formula to most pigment-based traditional stains.
  • They’re environment friendly and easy to brush or spray on.
  • Extended dry time can turn a fun project into an unbearable one and should be carefully considered before starting.
  • This isn’t the color I expected at all when looking at the color on the front of the can.
  • This stain will help protect the wood on your outdoor project from mold, mildew and ultraviolet rays and dries to a durable finish.
  • While varnish will make wood grains stand out to some extent, they can’t do so to the extent that wood stain can.
  • I believe that each method or product has it’s own downfalls.
  • They are very versatile and it’s fun to play around to get the look your after.

When buying exterior stain, check the opacity on the label to get the look you desire. Early American is our go-to dark wood stain color. We recently used it for our custom U-shaped desk. It has a bit or redness and warmth to it, so keep that in mind when planning your project. When paired with a redder wood, like the Oak, it can look pretty red.

What Is Polycrylic?

Yes, gel stains are VERY durable especially when top coated and sealed. Perfect for high traffic areas like doors and cabinets. They are oil-based so you have to wait at least 2-5 days (or until 100% DRY) to seal and topcoat but well worth it. Depending on the temperature and humidity, gel stains can feel dry to the touch in 6-8 hours but you should give them a proper 24 hours to dry between each coat. They don’t penetrate into the wood as traditional stains do.

Do keep in mind that stain colors can look different on different species and types of wood. So, it’s best to always test your stain out in a small area on your project first to see how it looks on your piece of wood before applying it to the whole project! Also, if you need tips on staining, see my how to stain wood tutorial and the best way to apply wood stain. This is designed to be a slow drying wood stain. In contrast to the fast drying thin translucent stains mentioned previously, this product offers a heavy-bodied, controllable interior wood stain. This product can be used on old or new bare wood but can also be used on finished wood.

Apply with a brush, cloth, or foam applicator , then wait 10 hours or overnight to re-coat. A solvent is necessary for cleanup, but there won’t be much to clean thanks to the gel stain’s no-mess application. 5.Minwax Jacobean.The first of the dark stains we tried was also the more neutral in tone. 4.Minwax Golden Oak.This is another mid-range stain color, but with a more neutral base undertone. Their oil based topcoat line doesn’t disappoint. They have easy to apply Wipe-on Oil based top coats that come in gel or liquid form.

You have two choices – strip the doors or paint. Or to get a cheap piece of furniture presentable for a few months while you are arranging its replacement. Now that I got that out of my head,back to the discussion. Other than the poster with 40 years experience,has anyone found an application where Polyshades will perform better than stain+clearcoat?

Oil-based polyurethane imparts a slight amber tone to the wood, so it’s probably not what you want over a pure-white painted finish. Polycrylic is not as durable as polyurethane and is meant to be used only on interior surfaces such as cabinets, furniture, and trim. It shouldn’t be used in exterior applications or on surfaces that are subject to lots of wear, such as floors, or that are exposed to water. There are other finishes, both solvent- and water-based, that are made specifically for floors and can handle the foot traffic. Varnishes that contain a larger amount of oil to resin are called long oil varnishes. Varnishes that contain a lower amount of oil are called medium oil varnishes.

Well, I cannot believe the difference in the depth of color and the quality of stain. I looked at the other project I had done in the last couple of years stained with Minwax and looked at the project I just did with Varethane and couldn’t believe the difference. So after seeing the difference, I went back to HD and bought some varathane poly, satin finish. The only difference I could discern with that, was the Varathene felt thicker, which honestly, I’m not sure I liked. Just like with other kinds of paints, wooden finishes may require more than one coat.

Most of the Varathane products smell oily while most of the Minwax products have some sort of antic smell when used on wood. They are permanent and bond well with the wood and are also easy to use; therefore you can do it by yourself. They, however, tend to dry unevenly especially when thicker layers are applied. They are advantageous as they come in two coats of the same color; giving either thicker or thinner coating according to preference. They provide a thick coating and a shiny and glossy appearance.

Toner—contains just a hint of pigment so the natural wood grain is visible. The wood types each also have a different natural color to them. This underlying color tone will obviously effect how the stain color appears on the wood, too.

I was really surprised by how dark and even all the poplar wood samples turned out! I love poplar for painted furniture builds, since it has tight grain that takes paint well. Apparently the same applies to black wood stain! You really can’t go wrong with any of these colors. The first coat of stain was allowed to soak in for exactly two minutes, then the excess was wiped off with a shop paper towel.

You should be careful when applying this product by making sure you don’t put too much on in a single coat. It may require more sanding than liquid stains because of its thickness. I know that some people apply this stain with rags but I find if I use a foam brush that I’m using less of the product. Some people may say ‘oh it’s not as fast’ but I’m okay with that, to me it’s all about application and getting it on evenly. This is one of my favorite products I use to restore wood furniture. I use it quite a bit on the tops of my furniture that I restore and there are a couple of things why I love this product so much.

The material will always look yellow on a white background, regardless of age. These finishes do get more yellow over time, but oil-based always has an amber/yellow tone to it. To test if it’s still good, apply some to a piece of wood and make sure it cures in a reasonable varathane vs minwax stain amount of time, like 12 hrs or so. Wiping tacky oil based stain back down with a rag soaked in stain will usually dissolve the excess stain, since the stain contains solvent. I also experienced a problem with a stain that remained sticky to the touch after about 8 hours.

Source: homemakerguide.com

Best Reviews

How To Apply Gel Stain To Finished Wood

However, because the wood is already saturated with these preservatives, it doesn’t soak up the stain quite as easily. This semi-transparent water-based stain is fortified with zinc to help prevent color loss over time. Wood sealer varathane vs minwax stain is the best finish to protect the wood from moisture, sun, and other weather conditions. This is an eco-friendly sealer that can be used indoors. We are in the process of re-finishing a sunroom porch that was built in the ’50s.

I should add, I did solid cherry butcher block countertops, kitchen cabinets painted Repose Gray . The cherry does not ‘show’ where any of the doors are. Probably, but you’d likely need a combo of stains and I’m not sure what that combo would be. Best practice would be to get a piece of walnut and do some tests. Perhaps someone could give me their opinions of what wood and stain to use with black iron pipe?

Varathane Classic Black

You can use thinning solutions with this stain. Any form of application brush or roller can be used. Some water-based stains are very watery, but this Whitewash from General Finishes is much thicker than other brands. It’s easy to apply with sponges and cloth rags. You can use it with a roller if you apply it slowly.

Instead, it’s best to use a nylon scrubby-type abrasive, such as 3M’s Scotch-Brite pads. When it comes to wood finish, which should you use? Read this guide to learn more about the differences between polyurethane and polycrylic. Minwax, or any other product for that matter, has carefully described prescriptions for the proper use of their product.

Our Favorite Gray Wood Stain

It could also be seen as a negative if the user doesn’t like to work with a thick-bodied stain. One strong positive that sets this product apart from other stains is that it can be used on both interior and exterior projects. If used outdoors, it does require that you add an additional coat of a clear protective finish. Old Master’s Wiping Stain is designed for interior applications but can be used as an exterior stain as well if topped with a clear protective finish.

The resin contained in a varnish is also important in determining what type to use for your project. Some resins are more elastic than others, making them best suited for exterior uses. Alkyd and polyurethanes are better suited for interior use. Not as important, but still a factor is what type of oil is used.

However, finishes also amplify defects, making it vital to address imperfections beforehand. Additionally, if the wood is not properly prepared, you may encounter difficulties getting the color to absorb. On the other hand, Varathane’s products are slightly less versatile. They’re best suited to finished interior wooden surfaces, such as cabinets and furniture. Each finish adds to the final color(except water based which generally dries clear.

Choosing wood finish depends on what you want to get in the end. Definitely, wood stain is for you if you want to keep the natural wood grain visible which I think the most important and beauteous thing of the wood piece. Stain will show the wood grain and make it look darker just as you desire. On the other hand, paint will cover wood grain but there are much more colors to choose from, but paints got less dark colors than stains.

I’ve done several wood projects, but I was considering using birch plywood for the first time. I had never used a pre-stain conditioner and also wanted to see the denefit of doing so. Your illustrations were fantastic and saved me from making a huge mistake.

I can say that a second or even third coat may be needed to get the desired color. Even in the two coat scenario, this clearly presents more effort and cost than the one coat alternatives. The fact that the color choices are limited to traditional wood grain hues might also present a downside for those wanting unusual colors.

Economics Of Wipe On Poly

Minwax Dark Walnut was the first stain color that I fell in love with when I first started woodworking. It’s the perfect, medium-dark wood stain with golden highlights that show through the wood grain. It think it looks even better when it’s finished with an oil based polyurethane which really enhances the dark walnut color and the grain of the wood. All the black wood stain colors were tested on birch plywood, maple, poplar, pine, and red oak. Each type came from the same board to avoid any differences in color. They were sanded up to 150 grit sandpaper, and were not treated with any kind of wood conditioner before applying the stain.

Five Expert-Recommended Wood Stain Brands – Science Times

Five Expert-Recommended Wood Stain Brands.

Posted: Fri, 19 Jul 2019 07:00:00 GMT [source]

There are several deep dark colors available, but java is my favorite. I can guarantee you will love this murky brown color, it turns out a little bit lighter after you apply it, but it still looks awesome. Depending on the pale section’s color you may use stain or oil.

Believe In Yourself Enough To Invest In Yourself And Your Projects!

My recollection of this article was that the winner was picked in advance. Various products were evaluated, when applied without respect to proper or recommended procedures, and with not too much evaluation criteria. I did a job for a guy shortly after that article came out. When there, he showed me his wood-turning shop.

But, it you desire a shiny, exterior film finish, the marine varnish is probably the most durable. Probably get two or three years of exposure before it looks bad. I’ve not used Varathane but every other brand of spar varnish I’ve used that came from a bix box store failed to hold up more than a year outdoors.

Varathane Vs Minwax: Which Is Best For Wood Finishing?

You need to have experience to know how to do this and know the right feel. If you do a 2nd coat of stain, it won’t adhere properly. Professional floor sanders know their trade very well and know how to “read” the floor well to know if it’s dry enough to apply polyurethane. And, if it isn’t dry enough, they will return the next day (as they know the cost of applying poly too soon (i.e. you need to start from scratch and sand the floors again). Just remember to always test your stain on a sample piece before applying it to your project. As the photo below reveals, the three gel stains we tried varied considerably in thickness.

Wood Finishes – Stain, Shellac, Oil, Varnish & Paint (The Basics) – BobVila.com

Wood Finishes – Stain, Shellac, Oil, Varnish & Paint (The Basics).

Posted: Sun, 06 Apr 2014 09:12:33 GMT [source]

/r/woodworking is your home on reddit for furniture, toys, tools, wood, glue, and anything else that has to do with woodworking as a hobby or profession. Please submit links to how-to pages and videos, pictures of beautiful and amazing pieces you made for us to admire, or help you finish. For stain, I’ve always had better results with Varathane than Minwax.

Polycrylic is not recommended for use over dark-colored paints or red mahogany stain, however, where it’s clear appearance can become somewhat opaque or milky. Minwax said „you have to sand it out and then apply an exterior stain” which is absolutely not an option. I’d rather just carve some money out of the contract for staining it again in a few years than that. The home is rustic cedar, so we want the rough finish. Obviously the time between stain and varnish application will be a factor. But if you didn’t experience major problems with beading of the waterbased poly as you were applying it I think you’re OK.

  • White wood is light, soft and straight grained.
  • Everything I’ve used makes my red oak look pink!
  • Use some medium sandpaper (#120 grit paper) and sand the wood if you are going to use a water-based stain.
  • Their water based properties make it easy to clean the repaired areas and they also blend well with stain colors.
  • You may need to go lighter with the exterior stain to keep it close to what you are looking to have.
  • After it’s applied, wipe the stain back and smooth it out with the tool of your choice.
  • The better the wood preparation, the better the final result.
  • As I mentioned previously on here this is what we have in our LR & DR and it seems much nicer than any poly we’ve ever had.

I then remove the outer surface with a 3000 psi pressure washer to remove the exterior surface, then respray the exterior with new transparent stain. There really is very little difference in durability for these 2 stains. I’ve seen some contractors claim that Duraseal lasts a bit longer because it penetrates the wood more. But, the truth of the matter is that the durability is driven much more by the quality of sanding job and the type, brand and number of coats of polyurethane use. Because gel stains lie on a wood surface instead of soaking into it, they uniformly color porous and nonporous areas alike. That makes them relatively goof-proof, and a great help to novice finishers.

As beautiful as they are, wish we had stuck with oak due to the hardness factor. There is not much worse than putting on the wrong stain, especially if you are working with dark ones. Seriously though, I came here looking for some ideas of which wood to use and which stain and now it’s even harder to decide what I want to do. I want a matt black stain with no shine at all. I would like the ‘old world’ type of look to the finish. Add Minwax Ebony color stain to this experiment!

Best and Worst Wood Stains From Consumer Reports’ Tests – ConsumerReports.org

Best and Worst Wood Stains From Consumer Reports’ Tests.

Posted: Tue, 03 Mar 2020 08:00:00 GMT [source]

Source: homemakerguide.com